The winter picture in four lines: Cheap flights from New York to Rome get scarcer on 25 October 2026, when Norse Atlantic pauses JFK to Fiumicino (FCO) until 27 March 2027. United drops Newark from two flights a day to one on 24 October. American's seasonal JFK flight is listed until 23 October. ITA Airways and Delta keep flying from JFK all winter. The nonstop is scheduled at 8 hours to 8 hours 40 minutes. Checked on 10 October 2026.
Here is the problem with advice written in July. In summer this is a five-airline route with a budget carrier keeping everyone honest. By the last week of October it is three airlines, all full-service, and the cheap seat you remember from a summer search may simply not exist. So the useful question for a winter or early spring trip is narrower: who is actually flying in your month, and is a connection now the better buy?
Month by month, who is on the route
- Until 24 October. ITA flies JFK two or three times a day, Delta twice, American once (its last departure is listed for 23 October), Norse three times a week, and United twice a day from Newark. That adds up to about eight departures a day.
- 25 October to mid-February. Norse is gone. United is down to one flight, which swaps to a smaller Boeing 767 from 5 January to 10 February. Delta stays at two a day. ITA continues, though it had not published a winter count we could verify. American is gone too. Its JFK flight is a summer service: schedule data shows the last departure on 23 October, American's winter filing lists London, Paris, Madrid, Milan and Barcelona from JFK and leaves Rome out, and no 2027 restart date has been published. The 2026 season began on 28 March, so a late March return is likely but not confirmed. That leaves ITA and Delta at JFK and United at Newark.
- From 13 February 2027. United's second Newark flight comes back, four days a week at first.
- Late March. Norse's suspension is listed to 27 March. Easter Sunday is 28 March 2027, one of the hardest weeks of the year to find a seat or a room in Rome, so book that week on an airline that is definitely flying.
Departures cluster in the evening: ITA at about 4:05pm, 5:35pm and 9:10pm, Delta at 5:30pm and 7:25pm, American around 8:00pm, United at 5:15pm from Newark. Take the 4:05pm and you are at Fiumicino at 6:40am, hours before any hotel will give you a room. The later flights land mid-morning. Flying home takes longer, around nine and a half to ten hours against the wind.
ITA changed teams, and your miles went with it
This one catches loyal Delta flyers out. ITA Airways used to be a SkyTeam airline and a Delta partner. It left SkyTeam in April 2025, the last ITA and Delta codeshare flights ran in August 2025, and on 1 April 2026 ITA became the 26th member of Star Alliance. Its old Volare program closed and members moved to Miles & More, the Lufthansa program. Lufthansa owns 41 percent of ITA and said in May 2026 it would raise that to 90 percent.
In practice: United MileagePlus and other Star Alliance members can now earn on ITA from JFK Terminal 1, and United sells ITA flights under its own code. ITA does not fly from Newark. Delta flyers have Delta's own two flights from Terminal 4. American and its oneworld partners use Terminal 8. Our roundup of the best airlines to fly to Italy compares the cabins.
Five cities worth one stop
With the budget nonstop parked for the winter, a connection is the main way to undercut the nonstop fare. Each of these airlines flew both halves of the trip when we checked:
- Dublin, Aer Lingus. Three flights a day from JFK and three a day on to Rome. On the way home you clear US immigration and customs in Dublin and land at JFK as a domestic passenger.
- Lisbon, TAP. About 31 flights a week between Lisbon and Rome; see Lisbon to Rome if you fancy breaking the journey.
- Madrid, Iberia. Two or three JFK flights a day and 45 a week on to Rome, and it earns oneworld miles.
- Reykjavik, Icelandair. The shortest first leg, but only about five Rome flights a week, so the dates must line up.
- Istanbul, Turkish Airlines. You overshoot Rome and come back, which adds hours. It earns Star Alliance miles.
A stop adds several hours each way. Whether that is worth it depends on the saving per person and on who is traveling; our guide to direct versus connecting flights has a simple way to price your own time.
Illustrated travel inspiration for Rome, from arrival to exploring the city.
From the jet bridge to a Roman front door
US passport holders are registered in the EU's Entry/Exit System on arrival: a kiosk takes fingerprints and a photo, and no stamp goes in the passport. A traveler report from September 2026 described kiosks followed by automatic gates that accepted US passports. That is one person's account, not an official statement, so leave slack after an early landing.
Then match the train to the neighborhood:
Termini, Monti, Esquilino. The Leonardo Express: 14 euros, about 32 minutes nonstop to Termini, every 15 minutes or so, first train from the airport at 5:38am. One child aged 4 to 11 rides free with each paying adult.
Trastevere, Testaccio, or a train north from Tiburtina. The FL1 regional train, about 8 euros. It does not go to Termini. It reaches Trastevere in about 31 minutes and Tiburtina in about 48, which makes it the smarter line for a lot of rental apartments.
Three or four people, or a 6:40am arrival with bags. A white city taxi at the fixed fare of 55 euros to anywhere inside the Aurelian Walls, luggage included. Buses to Termini start at about 4 euros with Terravision and 7 with SIT.
The London to Rome page goes deeper on which of these wins late at night, and the Rome guide on where to base yourself.
Small charges Rome added in 2026
The Jubilee year ended on 6 January 2026, and Rome has added two small entry charges since. Going down to the edge of the Trevi Fountain costs 2 euros, card only, from 9:00am to 10:00pm. The Pantheon went from 5 to 7 euros on 1 July. Colosseum tickets are sold in the holder's name, go on sale 30 days ahead and are checked against ID at the gate, so buy them yourself and bring your passport. The Vatican Museums close on Sundays except the last one of each month, when entry is free and the line is enormous.
Hotels add a city tax per person per night, charged for the first ten nights. A guide updated in February 2026 put it at 6 euros in a three star hotel and 10 in a five star; we could not open the city's own page to confirm.
Doing Paris as well? Flying into one city and home from the other saves a day of backtracking: compare New York to Paris.
What we read, and what we could not confirm
All checked on 10 October 2026.
- FlightsFrom timetable, JFK to Fiumicino and its Newark page for October flights and times.
- Aeroroutes filings for Norse Atlantic's winter suspension and United's winter schedule.
- ITA's alliance history from LoyaltyLobby's Star Alliance report and Aeroroutes' note on the end of the Delta codeshare.
- Trenitalia: Leonardo Express and Aeroporti di Roma: taxi fares.
- Turismo Roma on the Trevi Fountain charge and the Italian culture ministry's Pantheon notice.
- Aeroroutes on American's winter 2026/27 international schedule and Flightmapper's record for AA 236 (effective 28 March to 23 October 2026).
- Not confirmed: American's end date on aa.com (it comes from schedule databases), its 2027 restart date, ITA's winter frequency, Norse's return date, the FL1 fare on Trenitalia's own site, and the hotel tax on the city's site.
